peteg's blog - noise - movies - 2025 11 06 TheSmashingMachine

The Smashing Machine (2025)

/noise/movies | Link

The reviews were generally dire but I was curious to see what Benny Safdie could do without his brother Josh (Uncut Gems (2019)). The obvious referent is Aronofsky's The Wrestler (2008) and, like Mickey Rourke there, you cannot fault Dwayne Johnson's commitment. Apparently some parts are shot-for-shot remakes of The Smashing Machine (2002) and it is never clear why anyone wants that. (That was directed by John Hyams, making this an improbable jag from Capricorn One (1978).)

Fatally none of the characters have any depth; Emily Blunt's is the most annoying (she never got into the right register; there are plenty of American actresses who know how) though in mitigation they did equip her with a beautiful cat. Nala Sinephro (having a moment?) mangles The Star Spangled Banner, and this is proof that there are things that even Bruce Springsteen cannot elevate. Perhaps they should have cast Adam Sandler.

Dana Stevens: superficial. Peter Sobczynski: quite flawed. Both struggled to discern what the Safdie(s) are trying to say and why anyone should care. Jason Di Rosso interviewed the cinematographer Maceo Bishop.